My Father
91 points, My Score
Blue MMXXV
Chocolate , Cedar , Earth , Coffee
A very pleasant surprise.
Flavor
Cigars with coffee notes
-
-
Padrón
94 points, My Score
1964 Anniversary Maduro
Coffee , Espresso , Chocolate , Nuts
A very special Maduro. Not as dark or aggressive as many others, and that restraint is part of what makes it so elegant.
-
Ashton
87 points, My Score
Aged Maduro No. 20
Chocolate , Coffee , Molasses
A pleasant, well-constructed Maduro with a particularly attractive opening.
-
El Club del Turro
85 points, My Score
Escopeta
Chocolate , Coffee , Toast , Pepper
A well-constructed cigar with generous smoke production and a very defined personality.
-
Aladino
86 points, My Score
Classic Elegante
Spice , Wood , Cream , Cedar
A classic, traditional smoke with much more emphasis on spice and wood than on creaminess or sweetness.
-
Sobremesa
92 points, My Score
Brûlée
Cream , Cedar , Caramel , Honey
One of the better Connecticut experiences I’ve had recently.
-
La Aroma de Cuba
89 points, My Score
Connecticut — Corona
Cedar , Almond , Nuts , Toast
A Connecticut I genuinely enjoyed. Smooth and refined, but with enough flavor and structure to never feel light or empty.
-
Rocky Patel
83 points, My Score
Mulligans Masters Collection
Espresso , Coffee , Earth , Wood
A bold, structured cigar built around a dark, roasted profile.
-
Rolando Soto
88 points, My Score
Quynza Maduro
Chocolate , Coffee , Espresso , Cocoa
A small cigar with a surprisingly rich and satisfying personality.
-
Rolando Soto
87 points, My Score
Quynza Habano
Cedar , Wood , Coffee , Earth
Small format, plenty of character.
-
La Aroma de Cuba
88 points, My Score
Mi Amor — Belicoso
Cocoa , Espresso , Earth , Cedar
A familiar Mi Amor identity, expressed with a little more concentration and earthiness in the Belicoso format.
-
Romeo y Julieta
87 points, My Score
Capulet 75th Anniversary — Toro
Toast , Cream , Bread , Cedar
A Connecticut with plenty of character, leaning more toward toasted, nutty and structured flavors than overt creaminess.
-
CAO
88 points, My Score
FASA Sombra — Toro
Cream , Almond , Coffee , Hay
A Connecticut that genuinely surprised me. Not the creamiest expression of the style, but it delivers enough creaminess, natural sweetness and softness to create a very enjoyable experience.
-
Punch
84 points, My Score
Gran Puro Nicaragua — Robusto
Nuts , Earth , Coffee , Cedar
A well-constructed cigar with a clearly defined Nicaraguan character, built around earthy, roasted and nutty flavors.
-
El Cigarreño
90 points, My Score
Maduro Oscuro — Figurado / Torpedo
Chocolate , Cocoa , Espresso , Earth
This vitola showed me a better expression of El Cigarreño’s Maduro Oscuro. Compared with the Robusto Box Pressed, I found it more concentrated, flavorful and better integrated.
-
OZ Family
88 points, My Score
Karatoba — Toro Box Pressed
Toast , Coffee , Cedar , Earth
Ecuador Sumatra Wrapper
-
Rocky Patel
86 points, My Score
Mulligans Eagle Reserve — Churchill
Cocoa , Coffee , Cedar , Toast
A long, easygoing smoke built around cacao, roasted coffee and cedar.
-
Foundation
82 points, My Score
The Wise Man Maduro — Corona
Cocoa , Coffee , Earth , Pepper
A cigar I respected more than I enjoyed.
-
Camacho
86 points, My Score
Triple Maduro
Chocolate , Espresso , Earth , Coffee
Dark. Dense. Powerful. This cigar makes no attempt to hide what it is.
-
El Cigarreño
89 points, My Score
Maduro Oscuro — Robusto Box Pressed
Chocolate , Espresso , Cocoa , Earth
Dark, bold and beautifully balanced.
-
Arturo Fuente
92 points, My Score
Chateau Fuente Queen B Sun Grown
Espresso , Cocoa , Cedar , Earth
Some cigars impress with intensity. Others with precision.
-
Alfonso
91 points, My Score
Gran Selección
Chocolate , Espresso , Cocoa , Earth
Some cigars reveal themselves slowly.
-
Plasencia
87 points, My Score
Reserva Original — Nesticos
Earth , Cedar , Hay , Toast
Sometimes simplicity is exactly what the moment calls for.
-
El Club del Turro
87 points, My Score
El Chango Azul
Earth , Cedar , Coffee , Cocoa
There’s something different about smoking a cigar made in Puerto Rico.
-
Oliva
90 points, My Score
Serie V Melanio Maduro
Cocoa , Coffee , Espresso , Toast
A refined and well-balanced Maduro that delivered a much stronger experience than I remembered.
-
Rocky Patel
89 points, My Score
Special Reserve Sun Grown Maduro
Spice , Black Pepper , Cocoa , Coffee
A bold and complex cigar that surprised me in a very positive way.
-
Mayflower
85 points, My Score
Dawn Toro
Toast , Wood , Coffee , Almond
A well-constructed and balanced Connecticut with a lighter, more toasted expression than I initially expected.
-
Villiger
88 points, My Score
Exclusivo U.S.A. Gordo
Earth , Coffee , Toast , Wood
A well-executed Nicaraguan cigar with a defined profile and excellent balance.
-
Macanudo
82 points, My Score
Café Hyde Park
Cedar , Toast , Coffee , Wood
A classic, mild cigar whose greatest strengths were its construction and pairing potential.
-
Oliva
81 points, My Score
Connecticut Reserve Churchill
Cream , Cedar , Toast , Coffee
The opening draws were the highlight of the experience, delivering a creamy texture, natural sweetness, soft cedar, and light toasted nuts—exactly the qualities I enjoy in a Connecticut.
-
Falto
89 points, My Score
Mentor Toro
Cedar , Coffee , Toast , Earth
Some cigars impress through constant evolution. Others earn their place through consistency. The Falto Mentor belongs to the latter.
-
My Father
88 points, My Score
#5
Almond , Cedar , Coffee , White Pepper
A refined, well-constructed cigar that stood out more for its balance than for dramatic complexity.
-
Cohiba
88 points, My Score
Red Dot Churchill
Cedar , Almond , Coffee , Wood
The Churchill format allows this cigar to evolve at an unhurried pace, producing silky smoke and excellent balance from the first draw.
-
Aganorsa Leaf
89 points, My Score
Nica Libre Toro
Chocolate , Cedar , Spice , Coffee
A cigar that confidently showcases the classic Aganorsa character.
-
Reformed Cigars
93 points, My Score
ECO Maduro Grand Toro
Cocoa , Espresso , Earth , Toast
A cigar that proves strength and refinement can coexist.
-
Davidoff
94 points, My Score
Dominicana Corona Larga
Cedar , Almond , Cashew , Floral
A cigar that proves elegance doesn’t need intensity to be unforgettable.
-
Meerapfel
94 points, My Score
La Estancia Robusto
Cream , Toast , Cedar , Coffee
An elegant cigar doesn’t need to be overpowering to leave a lasting impression.
-
La Aroma de Cuba
88 points, My Score
Reserva Toro
Cedar , Espresso , Cocoa , Floral
A classic, balanced smoke that reminded me how enjoyable simplicity can be.
-
Rocky Patel
85 points, My Score
Mulligans Bogey Club
Toast , Coffee , Wood , Cream
Sometimes a cigar doesn’t need to be complex to be enjoyable.
-
Sr. Velázquez
82 points, My Score
Doble Capa (Barber Pole)
Cream , Coffee , Earth , Wood
The idea behind this cigar immediately caught my attention. Combining Connecticut and San Andrés wrappers in a barber pole format, it aims to bridge creamy and darker flavor profiles within the same experience.
-
-
-
Perdomo
88 points, My Score
20th Anniversary Maduro Robusto
Coffee , Cocoa , Wood
A cigar that impressed me more with its execution than its complexity.
-
612 Cigar Lounge
80 points, My Score
612 House Blend
Coffee , Wood , Earth
Curious to try the house blend from 612 Cigar Lounge, and I appreciated the opportunity to experience something created to represent a local Puerto Rican lounge.
-
Oliva
Serie V Melanio Maduro Robusto
Cocoa , Coffee , Wood
This experience reminded me how much cigar storage matters.
-
Punch
89 points, My Score
Diablo
Spice , Espresso , Wood , Coffee
This cigar surprised me in the best way possible.
-
Fratello
80 points, My Score
Sorella
Spice , Coffee , Earth
Trying something darker and more aggressive than my usual preference.
-
La Aroma de Cuba
85 points, My Score
Small Batch — Toro
Spice , Coffee , Cocoa , Toast
Taking a moment to slow things down after a heavy weekend.
-
Drew Estate
88 points, My Score
Undercrown Maduro — Toro
Cocoa , Coffee , Earth , Chocolate
End of the day. Slowing things down.
-
Hoyo de Monterrey
90 points, My Score
Epicure No. 2 — Robusto
Wood , Toast , Coffee , Floral
Somewhere between the cold air and a slower pace, I reached for this Cuban puro — paired with a local Icelandic rum that complemented the moment perfectly.
-
-
-
Arturo Fuente
90 points, My Score
Hemingway Work of Art
Cream , Spice , Toast , Coffee
Taking a step back.
-
-
Rocky Patel
84 points, My Score
Mulligans Calcutta Churchill
Toast , Nuts , White Pepper , Earth
Midday pause.
-
-
Partagás
92 points, My Score
Serie D No. 4
Coffee , Earth , Wood , Toast
Slowing things down for a moment. This is what I usually look for.
-
San Cristóbal
87 points, My Score
Revelation
Cocoa , Coffee , Wood , Toast
This one felt composed from the start. No tension. No need to prove anything.
