Padrón
94 points, My Score
1964 Anniversary Maduro
Coffee , Espresso , Chocolate , Nuts
A very special Maduro. Not as dark or aggressive as many others, and that restraint is part of what makes it so elegant.
Flavor
Cigars with leather notes
-
-
Romeo y Julieta
85 points, My Score
1875 — Churchill
Leather , Cedar , Toast , Nuts
A classic, well-defined cigar with solid construction and a very traditional profile.
-
Reformed Cigars
92 points, My Score
C.H. Spurgeon Dark Blue Maduro
Cocoa , Espresso , Nuts , Earth
This is what I want from a serious Maduro: dark, full-bodied and rich, but still balanced and clearly defined.
-
Camacho
86 points, My Score
Triple Maduro
Chocolate , Espresso , Earth , Coffee
Dark. Dense. Powerful. This cigar makes no attempt to hide what it is.
-
Argyle
88 points, My Score
Turf Club Robusto
Chocolate , Earth , Leather , Spice
A bold cigar with a dark, full-bodied profile.
-
Cohiba
88 points, My Score
Red Dot Churchill
Cedar , Almond , Coffee , Wood
The Churchill format allows this cigar to evolve at an unhurried pace, producing silky smoke and excellent balance from the first draw.
-
Arturo Fuente
95 points, My Score
Don Carlos Personal Reserve
Cedar , Almond , Leather , Cocoa
Some cigars impress with strength. This one impressed me with elegance.
-
Perdomo
87 points, My Score
10th Anniversary Maduro Epicure
Hay , Toast , Leather , Earth
Exceptional construction from start to finish.
-
Sancho Panza
85 points, My Score
Extra Chido
Chocolate , Earth , Leather , Cocoa
This cigar made its intentions clear from the cold draw—dark chocolate, earth, and leather pointed toward a bold, full-bodied experience.
-
Gran Habano
85 points, My Score
Corojo Vintage 2002
Leather , Earth , Spice , Cream
I expected a classic profile, and that’s exactly what I found.
-
Willy's Cigars
91 points, My Score
Shorty
Cocoa , Earth , Leather
What I expected to be a quick smoke turned into a surprisingly complete experience.
-
La Gloria Cubana
87 points, My Score
Serie R Maduro
Espresso , Cocoa , Leather , Earth
This cigar exceeded my expectations.
-
Punch
89 points, My Score
Diablo
Spice , Espresso , Wood , Coffee
This cigar surprised me in the best way possible.
-
ADVentura
Blue Eyed Jack’s Revenge Robusto
Earth , Leather , Spice
A very different experience than expected.
-
Rocky Patel
84 points, My Score
Mulligans Calcutta Churchill
Toast , Nuts , White Pepper , Earth
Midday pause.
